- Joined
- Nov 24, 2008
- Messages
- 11,998
- Reputation score
- 431
Re: Secret Hitler Game 1: It Begins (7 Players)
Without further ado, Alisa casts her vote.
Without further ado, Alisa casts her vote.
"Nein, you misunderstand. I mean ze first time around, vhen you vere our president. You could easily have discarded a liberal policy, and by ze time you were a chancellor again under Alisa, ve vould have no way of knowing zat there vas even a liberal policy left. Ze same situation could have happened for any of our presidents who supposedly discarded a fascist policy, including Lena, so Erika is right zat ve can't know for sure who is liberal or fascist, so we can't immediately assume Lena is trustworthy as you have suggested, especially since she has voted against you and Alisa last time around vhich she has still not answered.""Fraulein Brigitte--ja, zat instance alone ist not undeniable proof zat I am liberal, perhaps zat is true. Vat I am saying zough, is zat I am liberal and zat my actions haf been consistent vith my claim und belief.
If I vere to haf received a liberal and fascist policy instead of a fascist und fascist like I claim, zen you imply Alisa vas also lying? If I discarded a liberal policy instead, Alisa vould haf immediately accused me of lying if she vere liberal. Zas, if zat last gofernment were supposedly any indicator of me being fascist, zen Alisa vould haf to be one too. Vereas she could easily haf lied about receiving 3 fascist policies, und gotten 2 fascist und 1 liberal, discarding the liberal, und I'd be none ze wiser. Most likely, she ist telling ze truth, or going to great lengths to play me for a fool. Maybe a Fascist vould haf used ze opportunity to call me a liar. I shall have to ponder zis."
"Nein, you misunderstand. I mean ze first time around, vhen you vere our president. You could easily have discarded a liberal policy, and by ze time you were a chancellor again under Alisa, ve vould have no way of knowing zat there vas even a liberal policy left. Ze same situation could have happened for any of our presidents who supposedly discarded a fascist policy, including Lena, so Erika is right zat ve can't know for sure who is liberal or fascist, so we can't immediately assume Lena is trustworthy as you have suggested, especially since she has voted against you and Alisa last time around vhich she has still not answered."