DTT4 - Day 2
- Thread starter Ryu
- Start date
- Joined
- Nov 24, 2008
- Messages
- 11,998
- Reputation score
- 431
Re: DTT4 - Day 2
There are six people alive. Still, if Gremlin claims to have received a PM and you claim to have received a PM, you could both be demons. But I believe you. removed vote
There are six people alive. Still, if Gremlin claims to have received a PM and you claim to have received a PM, you could both be demons. But I believe you. removed vote
Last edited:
- Joined
- Nov 10, 2008
- Messages
- 971
- Reputation score
- 58
Re: DTT4 - Day 2
So there are, my bad. However, one of our players hasn't made a single post, and isn't likely to contribute to the lynch. The issue still stands though, because with two demons, they can kill two people.
In fact, I don't think it was Aika who converted Gremlin. I think it was, in fact, Dreana. That would explain how she died in the night, since we have no role that could do that. Since Diagasvesle's death proved her to be lying, she knew she would die anyway and decided to convert someone while she still could. Probably.
So there are, my bad. However, one of our players hasn't made a single post, and isn't likely to contribute to the lynch. The issue still stands though, because with two demons, they can kill two people.
In fact, I don't think it was Aika who converted Gremlin. I think it was, in fact, Dreana. That would explain how she died in the night, since we have no role that could do that. Since Diagasvesle's death proved her to be lying, she knew she would die anyway and decided to convert someone while she still could. Probably.
Last edited:
- Joined
- Nov 9, 2008
- Messages
- 3,042
- Reputation score
- 182
Re: DTT4 - Day 2
You see, if dreana had been the nurse, then the demons might have killed whichever one of plmnko and Gremlin is telling the truth, and then we'd know 100% that the other was a demon.
Anyway, my vote stands, even though there's a chance that gremlin is actually the demon.
Also I'm still undecided over whether hooker or bartnum is the final demon, but there's only one way to find out.
EDIT:
Because we were sure that Siphon was going to be alive the next day and also protected the the priestess, so there was no need to divulge any information to the public that the demons might not know.
You see, if dreana had been the nurse, then the demons might have killed whichever one of plmnko and Gremlin is telling the truth, and then we'd know 100% that the other was a demon.
Guesses, guesses, guesses, and all based off very flawed logic. I'll have you know that I cannot be a parasite demon, since I was targetted by a demon night 1. Also, nobody has countered my priestess claim ever.
If your previoius (flawed) theory was true, there would be 3 demons - me, the person I converted night 1, the person dreana just converted. So the game would have ended.
We don't have to lynch today actually, but we should since we have this 50/50 chance with plmnko and gremlin. We should definitely not be lynching anyone else though.
This is a fair enough accusation, it is entirely plausable that I was converted and that Gremlin is the other demon. However, being the priestess, I have been saving myself from conversion every night (I was going to save Siphon, but the nurse died so I knew his time was at an end). Of course you only have my word for that, but I think you'll agree that if you were the priestess yourself, that is what you would do.
Anyway, my vote stands, even though there's a chance that gremlin is actually the demon.
Also I'm still undecided over whether hooker or bartnum is the final demon, but there's only one way to find out.
EDIT:
Wow, at last a bit of sense coming from your mouth. What do you mean probably? There is no other reason why dreana would have died, she has 100% definitely attempted a convert. And unless it was on me, it succeeded.
- Joined
- Nov 10, 2008
- Messages
- 971
- Reputation score
- 58
Re: DTT4 - Day 2
I fixed that flawed logic in my last post.
That's because you never MADE a Priestess claim. To Siphon, maybe, but not to us. And Siphon didn't tell us.
I mean, that's what I think she thought. I'm not a mind reader, so I don't know for certain. But indeed, it is the only possible way she could have died.
- Joined
- Nov 9, 2008
- Messages
- 3,042
- Reputation score
- 182
Re: DTT4 - Day 2
Why would the real priestess lie to Siphon about their role day 1?
If there had been two priestess claims, would Siphon have really not said anything, never mind use me as his main consultant?
Seriously Bartnum, wtf.
Please tell me that's not serious.
Why would the real priestess lie to Siphon about their role day 1?
If there had been two priestess claims, would Siphon have really not said anything, never mind use me as his main consultant?
Seriously Bartnum, wtf.
- Joined
- Nov 24, 2008
- Messages
- 11,998
- Reputation score
- 431
Re: DTT4 - Day 2
I've already said that I'm the desperate girl. If no-one counters aika's claim, there's still only 50% chance that plmnko is a demon. I'd suggest that everyone claims to aika, but that wouldn't improve our chances to lynch the right person, and aika is dead anyway.
I've already said that I'm the desperate girl. If no-one counters aika's claim, there's still only 50% chance that plmnko is a demon. I'd suggest that everyone claims to aika, but that wouldn't improve our chances to lynch the right person, and aika is dead anyway.
- Joined
- Nov 10, 2008
- Messages
- 971
- Reputation score
- 58
Re: DTT4 - Day 2
You don't deny, then, that you never claimed to anyone but Siphon?
In that case, the only possible way that someone could have countered it was to claimed Priestess to Siphon as well. They knew he would tell you. And not everyone trusted you. I never did. Look at Diagasvesle. The nurse, an extremely vital role, and she never told Siphon. Why not the Priestess? How do we know she told Siphon anything at all? And in case you suggest that the Real priestess should now come forward to counter your claim, there is no proof that Gremlin wasn't the Priestess before she was converted.
In fact, thinking on it, we don't even know whether or not you really claimed to be the Priestess until just now. And Siphon's dead, so we can't ask him.
You don't deny, then, that you never claimed to anyone but Siphon?
In that case, the only possible way that someone could have countered it was to claimed Priestess to Siphon as well. They knew he would tell you. And not everyone trusted you. I never did. Look at Diagasvesle. The nurse, an extremely vital role, and she never told Siphon. Why not the Priestess? How do we know she told Siphon anything at all? And in case you suggest that the Real priestess should now come forward to counter your claim, there is no proof that Gremlin wasn't the Priestess before she was converted.
In fact, thinking on it, we don't even know whether or not you really claimed to be the Priestess until just now. And Siphon's dead, so we can't ask him.
- Joined
- Nov 10, 2008
- Messages
- 971
- Reputation score
- 58
- Joined
- Nov 24, 2008
- Messages
- 11,998
- Reputation score
- 431
Re: DTT4 - Day 2
If she were the priestess she could have prevented the converting.
If she were the priestess she could have prevented the converting.
- Joined
- Nov 24, 2008
- Messages
- 11,998
- Reputation score
- 431
Re: DTT4 - Day 2
Gremlin. Therefore if she is priestess she would still be priestess.
Gremlin. Therefore if she is priestess she would still be priestess.
- Joined
- Nov 10, 2008
- Messages
- 971
- Reputation score
- 58
Re: DTT4 - Day 2
She would have had to target herself, and under the circumstances, she was more likely to have chosen Siphon. We already know she got the PM.
But in any case, even if she was, and still is the Priestess, then we know Aika is lying to us.
She would have had to target herself, and under the circumstances, she was more likely to have chosen Siphon. We already know she got the PM.
But in any case, even if she was, and still is the Priestess, then we know Aika is lying to us.
- Joined
- Nov 24, 2008
- Messages
- 11,998
- Reputation score
- 431
Re: DTT4 - Day 2
You know what? Screw you both. vote removed
You know what? Screw you both. vote removed
Last edited:
- Joined
- Nov 24, 2008
- Messages
- 11,998
- Reputation score
- 431
Re: DTT4 - Day 2
There's no reason not to think that you're a demon. You're PM's authenticity was provided by Gremlin who you yourself claimed to be a demon. Aika also claimed that he's a demon. If it's any comfort, I don't really believe that you're a demon. But we don't have any convincing evidence for anyone, apparently. You've convinced yourself that aika is a demon based on a PM which doesn't prove it.
There's no reason not to think that you're a demon. You're PM's authenticity was provided by Gremlin who you yourself claimed to be a demon. Aika also claimed that he's a demon. If it's any comfort, I don't really believe that you're a demon. But we don't have any convincing evidence for anyone, apparently. You've convinced yourself that aika is a demon based on a PM which doesn't prove it.
- Joined
- Nov 9, 2008
- Messages
- 3,042
- Reputation score
- 182
Re: DTT4 - Day 2
I'm going to make a summary post.
Bartnum - Huge suspicion on me, unclear why, except for a final PM from Siphon. Keeps trying to think of plausable ways why I am a demon. Seems to think his claim of a role of which there are 2 alive is worthwhile, whilst my still uncountered claim of priestess must be flawed in some way.
Me - Only priestess claim, Siphon blatantly trusted me before she died, and it's very clear that my claim to her was the priestess.
Hooker - Not much to go on except that she doesn't seem to care about the village winning because keeps doing strange things with her lynch vote, e.g. voting to lynch someone who has less than 50% chance of being a demon.
Plmnko and Gremlin - One of them is a Parasite demon. Before someone tries to say this might not be true, they both claimed normal girl to Siphon yesterday and I'm sure they'll both still agree this is true today.
CloudXDP - Has hardly done anything this whole game. This really isn't helpful as we need input from everyone.
I'm going to make a summary post.
Bartnum - Huge suspicion on me, unclear why, except for a final PM from Siphon. Keeps trying to think of plausable ways why I am a demon. Seems to think his claim of a role of which there are 2 alive is worthwhile, whilst my still uncountered claim of priestess must be flawed in some way.
Me - Only priestess claim, Siphon blatantly trusted me before she died, and it's very clear that my claim to her was the priestess.
Hooker - Not much to go on except that she doesn't seem to care about the village winning because keeps doing strange things with her lynch vote, e.g. voting to lynch someone who has less than 50% chance of being a demon.
Plmnko and Gremlin - One of them is a Parasite demon. Before someone tries to say this might not be true, they both claimed normal girl to Siphon yesterday and I'm sure they'll both still agree this is true today.
CloudXDP - Has hardly done anything this whole game. This really isn't helpful as we need input from everyone.
- Joined
- Nov 10, 2008
- Messages
- 971
- Reputation score
- 58
Re: DTT4 - Day 2
I think it's very clear why I think you're a Demon. And I've already posted a very plausible theory. Your claim of Priestess IS flawed, because the real priestess may have been converted. And I'm just role claiming to stop myself from being lynched. I don't fancy being killed by my own side before this is all over.
In addition, Siphon said in his PM that he may have made a huge mistake in trusting you. We don't know what you told him. He can't validate it. You could be telling us a pack of lies. How do we know you claimed to be the Priestess? You never posted it.
This 'Summary Post' of yours is nothing but Psychological manipulation. 'Seems to think/Keeps trying to think/Huge suspicion, unclear why etc, that's all there to try and make my theory look wrong, because you know damn well it isn't.
Plmnko/Gremlin - 'One of them is a Parasite Demon'. That's what you're telling us. We don't know it, and you can't prove it. You're stating it like it's a fact in order to make it seem like one.
Summary Post? Load of Bollocks post is more like it.
As for Plmnko and Gremlin role claiming to Siphon, we don't know that they did, and Siphon isn't here to confirm it. Plmnko, who I believe is indeed the normal girl, may have done, but Gremlin, being a demon, could lie. As said, we couldn't prove it.
In fact, I've just thought of a brilliant way to settle this.
Let's lynch Gremlin. A person who I believe to be a demon, and who you say has a 50% chance of being one. We'll both be satisfied.
I VOTE LYNCH GREMLIN.
I think it's very clear why I think you're a Demon. And I've already posted a very plausible theory. Your claim of Priestess IS flawed, because the real priestess may have been converted. And I'm just role claiming to stop myself from being lynched. I don't fancy being killed by my own side before this is all over.
In addition, Siphon said in his PM that he may have made a huge mistake in trusting you. We don't know what you told him. He can't validate it. You could be telling us a pack of lies. How do we know you claimed to be the Priestess? You never posted it.
This 'Summary Post' of yours is nothing but Psychological manipulation. 'Seems to think/Keeps trying to think/Huge suspicion, unclear why etc, that's all there to try and make my theory look wrong, because you know damn well it isn't.
Plmnko/Gremlin - 'One of them is a Parasite Demon'. That's what you're telling us. We don't know it, and you can't prove it. You're stating it like it's a fact in order to make it seem like one.
Summary Post? Load of Bollocks post is more like it.
As for Plmnko and Gremlin role claiming to Siphon, we don't know that they did, and Siphon isn't here to confirm it. Plmnko, who I believe is indeed the normal girl, may have done, but Gremlin, being a demon, could lie. As said, we couldn't prove it.
In fact, I've just thought of a brilliant way to settle this.
Let's lynch Gremlin. A person who I believe to be a demon, and who you say has a 50% chance of being one. We'll both be satisfied.
I VOTE LYNCH GREMLIN.
Last edited: