Re: Monster Girl Quest
However as somebody on the Ntelliware forum pointed out, that could end badly in the same light as the Hot Coffee mod killed GTA San Andreas, leading Rockstar Games into a series of lawsuits and recalls, so we are debating once more how to handle things.
The current top thought is to release a rated version (Censored and dumbed down) and an unrated (no censorship at all). The product keys would be interchangeable, so if you bought the rated version, you could download the unrated version and your product key would work for it as well, and vice versa.
To use your example, it would be like if a movie producer got permission to remake Nightmare on Elm Street, but without a rating of R or below, studios won't fund it and movie stores won't carry it, and the MPAA just announced that movies containing images of nightmares are now NC-17. You could make an unrated movie, but you don't have the money to make it and it wouldn't get enough publicity without the marketing. So, you can either give up, change everything, or play by the rules and make an R-rated version to get the movie funded and out in the open, then simulatneously make an unrated version to release. That way you get funded and you can now remake Nightmare On Elm Street. Stores agree to carry the rated version, which generates publicity for both the rated and unrated versions. And in the end, you got to make the unrated version you wanted to and mass distribute it as if it were R-rated. It's basically just bending the rules.
To be totally honest, the biggest reason for hiding the sexual content by default is for money. Ntelliware is just starting out, Hero will be our first title, and in order to make it we need to raise about $20k. While the idea has been pitched by a few fans about accepting donations and offering rewards similar to a kickstarter project, the odds of it raising 20k are very slim, whereas Kickstarter gets more pulicity and would have a better chance. But in order to comply with kickstarter, the game has to be non-pornographic. So the best running idea is to get a non-pornographic version funded, and while developing it, simultaneously develop the full version of MGQ 3D. If anybody has a better idea to raise 20k, we'd be happy to not even worry about making an M rated version, would be easier on us anyhow. But if not, then this is the best we got.
So for those who want an accurate 3D remake of MGQ, you'll get it don't worry, we just have to make a non-hentai version too.
Thanks for the well written feedback! I fully agree with you. As I said earlier, the game is being made to fit the explicitness and sexual style of MGQ, with full hardcore H-scenes, but then censored so to speak, with a DLC to remove the censorship. Kind of like 3D Custom Girl, it is censored by default, but there are mods to remove the censorship.I read about the reasons that pushed you to make this game, and are the same that made you choose to make it non hentai.
I can understand those reasons but none the less I feel a non Hentai Monster girl quest loses most of it's charm.
And no, I'm not strictly talking about "fappability". Just that is a kind of setting and story that works on the premise to be Really explicit.
I read you want to keep the general notion that monster girls are somewhat sexually imposing and out to rape the humans but still... for example, one thing is to tell me that if the big zombie girl beats me she will rape me and I will be forced to be raped by a dead girl for an entire year.
Another thing is to actually see the miserable state of luka after that kind of treatment. The contrast between the philosofical horror of being raped by an undead and the objective fact that... she is Made for giving unbearable pleasure by design, and no matter what you do to resist that, you are going to succumb eventually.
I feel that to take that away from the game would be something like a remake of nightmare on Elm Street where you don't see any actual nightmare scene, you are just told that there is a dead psycho who can kill you in your dreams and you see people that falls asleep and dies in a mysterious way.
Then again, you plan to make a hentai DLC with the sex scenes. I fear that would do very little to bring back what MGQ is all about.
Because all in all you take a game about seduction and turn it in a game about brute physical confrontation with a game over rape, and I have nothing against game over Rape games, but the beauty of MGQ is that sex is a weapon. a deadly one.
Is a strugle against temptation more than it is a physical struggle. Actually, there are very few enemies based on pure physical aggression.
As much as I would like to see your final results I wonder if you would do a better job doing either a game with no monster girls and no sex involved that takes inspiration from the various plot hooks you find interesting in the game or a full fledged rendition of MGQ 3d based on explicit sex as it is meant to be.
I would probably play them both instead of a shaky middle ground.
However as somebody on the Ntelliware forum pointed out, that could end badly in the same light as the Hot Coffee mod killed GTA San Andreas, leading Rockstar Games into a series of lawsuits and recalls, so we are debating once more how to handle things.
The current top thought is to release a rated version (Censored and dumbed down) and an unrated (no censorship at all). The product keys would be interchangeable, so if you bought the rated version, you could download the unrated version and your product key would work for it as well, and vice versa.
To use your example, it would be like if a movie producer got permission to remake Nightmare on Elm Street, but without a rating of R or below, studios won't fund it and movie stores won't carry it, and the MPAA just announced that movies containing images of nightmares are now NC-17. You could make an unrated movie, but you don't have the money to make it and it wouldn't get enough publicity without the marketing. So, you can either give up, change everything, or play by the rules and make an R-rated version to get the movie funded and out in the open, then simulatneously make an unrated version to release. That way you get funded and you can now remake Nightmare On Elm Street. Stores agree to carry the rated version, which generates publicity for both the rated and unrated versions. And in the end, you got to make the unrated version you wanted to and mass distribute it as if it were R-rated. It's basically just bending the rules.
To be totally honest, the biggest reason for hiding the sexual content by default is for money. Ntelliware is just starting out, Hero will be our first title, and in order to make it we need to raise about $20k. While the idea has been pitched by a few fans about accepting donations and offering rewards similar to a kickstarter project, the odds of it raising 20k are very slim, whereas Kickstarter gets more pulicity and would have a better chance. But in order to comply with kickstarter, the game has to be non-pornographic. So the best running idea is to get a non-pornographic version funded, and while developing it, simultaneously develop the full version of MGQ 3D. If anybody has a better idea to raise 20k, we'd be happy to not even worry about making an M rated version, would be easier on us anyhow. But if not, then this is the best we got.
So for those who want an accurate 3D remake of MGQ, you'll get it don't worry, we just have to make a non-hentai version too.