I mean, F95's sole reason for being shit is it's moderation staff being hypocrites and losers. Besides that though it's a very useful site. They had a massive boast in popularity thanks to their reach on 4chan and great website UI layout. It's the go to site for western H game sharing for the most part, alongside all the helpful/not so helpful talk you would have seen from a place like Hongfire back in the day. Arguably it's what ULMF shoulda been but never took off for the most part, though to be fair back when ULMF started there were more useful alternatives for H games due to ulmf's lack of link sharing and no loli/requesting rules, sites like Hongfire and Nihongo. No one can truly understand on what a site is or isn't besides the creators or whatever of F95 and ULMF anyway.
Arguably it's what ULMF shoulda been but never took off for the most part, though to be fair back when ULMF started there were more useful alternatives for H games due to ulmf's lack of link sharing and no loli/requesting rules, sites like Hongfire and Nihongo.
God was it really as far back as 2012 when the rules were changed? Then I again, I suppose it has been five years since the server update broke the old forum... doesn't feel that long ago.
Anyway, it was never against the rules to post links (Hongfire was the one that banned links to dlsite games, because they were running ads for dlsite), only begging was banned, and it was pretty much a given that if a thread for a game was posted a link would also be shared, as hhh7773 will attest.
Not much else to be expected from a forum dedicated to pirating, and hell this forum once upon a time was in a somewhat similar position
I still vaguely remember this being a sharing community even way back when we were squatting on the comments of the last post of an abandoned blog, praying for the second coming of LM.
A big difference I guess back then was that a lot of stuff (western anyway) were just hobby projects and so were free, or done for commission like Toonpimp.
And Japanese devs were far more isolated, but they too produced a lot of freebies.
I do remember a time though when you'd search for a hentai game and the top result on google would be to a ulmf thread, so ulmf did take off and was the top dog for quite a while.
Which is what led to its downfall, it became a victim of its own success, because instead of a link going down (or an update being released) and a single person requesting a reup you'd suddenly get half a dozen single digit post having twat waffle lurkers all spamming a thread instead of just being patient. But instead of dealing with that specific problem of those specific types of poster instead the imo draconian rule of outright banning any requests for links was made, which caused the aforementioned confusion that links in general were banned.
Another issue was that ULMF's peak popularity was right when crowdfunding became the latest trend (thanks Chris Roberts, you absolute cunt) and suddenly every talentless hack with a dream (and not even a tech demo or sometimes not even screenshots) came flooding in with their low effort OPs to shill for subscribers and try and get rich quick, and unfortunately the mod team were just too slow to react to enforce a standards rule.
Granted this is an issue that has continued on to F95 too, with a bulk of threads being badly made 0.01s; but at least on there threads have be requested and can't just be posted and dumped by some randomer.