Re: (Nutaku) Milenium War Aigis (English Version)
Let's do this point for point since it is extremely good feedback and exactly what I'm looking for to make this better before its 'official' version is made.
My definitions are somewhat wonky. As it is an extension of the much more simplified list. IT was essentially units with 1 (2 in some cases) block with the stats need to take on a boss 1 on 1 and win(needed a healer not counting against).
-Angels were placed there simply because in the simplified list that is where they were placed. As on that list, a duelist was a 'boss fighter'. Angels have the stats to do that, and back in those days, I don't think the term gateway unit was ever used. Lightning rods I'm not exactly sure how to place that... that it wouldn't simply be any unit that could survive a large attack. I mean back then I used my Karma or Clissa for that role. While Karma would definitely fit the definition. Clissa wouldn't.
-She was placed there more for her class. Since with the ranged DPS from melee slot role (named Advance Ranged right now) had a ruling for the units base stat being capable of ranged attacks. So, for example, Sherry wouldn't appear there due to her SAW. Miruno was ruled not to fit since her base state was non-attacking.
-Hermits where under the Advance Ranged role as well as Duelist. Puppeteers are there due to lack of a Gateway role and the fact that I mostly saw they used as Duelist in the past with their skill being used to avoid having to withdraw them when they got low.
-I'd call her more of a ganker than a staller. Karma and her platinum version were always recommended to be drop in, take out a threat, and get out before they die. Though the reason she was pushed out to the duelist role was that of the decision to make gankers has a little impact on your UP as possible. Both versions were over the 6 UP limit chosen.
-This simply tells me the ganker role needs to have redone criteria
- Hmm... Thanks for the name. It sounds much better than "Anti-Swarm". As for Oni noted.
- I was really unsure of where to place them as duelist or tanks. So with your input, I'll place them as such. They had more than enough defense.
- That is very true. I've mostly seen swordmaster used in 'sweeping roles'. Mostly Sandra taking out a massive amount of flyers.
- Both Vampire Lords were placed as Stallers and Duelist. The Staller role doesn't normally prevent them from being placed in other roles(unlike Duelist and Tank would), and I've already mentioned about how gankers were sorted.
- Dragon Riders, Noted
- Well, Gankers are a more specific duelist. So if they fit into it I just left them out of the Duelist role. Also Prime Duelist?
-Oh really? Well, the distinction should be easy enough. Since unlike Royal Guards they have gotten their 2AW. If they go the Battle Maid route they will be placed as Duelist and if they go Armor Maid route they will be placed as Tanks. This is in addition to their buffer role.
- Noted, and people choose to use Saria's skill over her SAW? This is a surprise.
- Maribel, Noted
- What would be your definition of a staller?
Changes (other than units moving around) due to feedback.
-Gateway role will be added.
-Anti-Swarm will become Sweeper
-Ganker redefined, elimination of UP cost association.
