Re: [RJ120635] [Eclipse works] Ariadne
Welcome to mid 2012-present. Old, fat, dirty, horrendously repulsive men in EVERYTHING. I guess it's impossible to denigrate a woman unless you look like you were born from the ugly tree, and then viciously beaten by it for years.
First, let me be clear in that I have no particular prejudice towards either fat people or nerds (if I am definitely not fat, I probably qualify as a nerd, being on this forum and all).
Next, it is exactly as you say. While I can respect someone's fetishes like anyone else, even more so if they appear in a game not of my doing (I just could create my own, I guess), there's a thing or two worth being said about boring repetitiveness and room for exploring other fetishes than those that we get to see over and over and over again in every fucking damn H-game released recently.
I have no illusion about it going to continue, and "Nippon always going to Nippon" in matters of eroges, but if I could motivate at least ONE author to come up with something different (dare I say mature and original?) in the future, especially if they aim to target a gaijin public (which also can appreciate this particular kind of games and does have money to spend on them, mind you), I feel it would be worth it.
So what is different you might ask ? For one, if the usual premise seems good to me, setting a hero/heroine in a predicament (being captured, abused, whatever), I would love to see it happening in a context/story that doesn't insult the intelligence of the average player.
Blackmailing as threat is good for narrative purposes if it's "believable". Eroge games created twenty years ago managed to present such situations in much more credible (and arousing!) ways than it's done nowadays. I don't want H-games/VNs to become anything "intellectual" or literary masterpieces overnight, if ever (like your usual pr0n movie, they're created with fapping in mind, first and foremost).
However, proof with this game (and others, like Arms Devicer, Haru Uru, Princess Sacrifice, Vampire Princess Heart, Sword Princess Cistina, etc., etc.) that you don't fucking need to make your eroge hero/heroine so fucking dumb, or the molesters so fucking outlandish (for the huge majority of players anyway), that the game is facepalming inducing instead of fap worthy. If I feel compelled to laugh at the sheer "stupidity" of some situations in-game, I feel the H-game achieves the contrary of what it should (and what I potentially would have bought it for).
So yeah, I'd love to see a H-game with REAL mind fuckery, with real corruption (not the fairly land-one, in which dirty old men/fat nerds somehow always seem to get the best spoils) or BDSM situations that come close to the real thing, because that's what appeals to me as an "adult/mature" fetish. I'd love to play a game in which the hero/heroine gets to be molested because of cunning deception, or because of threats that can be perceived as credible, either as a true danger ("say hello to my friend the knife here?") or as something that could potentially be very satisfying sexually but with huge risks.
Ideally the game would also give the player the option to actually turn the tides at the very end, and seek vengeance (like I've explained in my previous post). Gosh, I would buy the crap out of this DLsite release.
Keep producing/torrenting your standard mindnumbing nukiges, why not, I am (mostly) against any kind of censoring, but make the above happen one day, please. There's hope with good games like this one I guess, and AA2 in the near future hopefully being more challenging/interesting than a simple dress-my-doll clickfest too.