- Joined
- Aug 12, 2010
- Messages
- 7,070
- Reputation score
- 192
Re: DTT: game on!
Let me address the two "flaws" that you found, DeMatt.
IF the demon declares herself special:
Then we have 4 cleared normal girls, and three suspects.
Next step is to say, "Okay, now good specials declare which special you ACTUALLY are." Seer says she's the seer. Protector says she's the protector. Evil now has to counter one and only one of those claims. Whichever person she doesn't counter is now clear as well giving us:
5 cleared vs two uncleared, one of which is evil. We lynch one of them, if game isn't over, we lynch the remaining one the next day and good is guaranteed victory.
************
Second scenario: Evil hits the protected seer, resulting in no death.
That means that after a day one lynch of a normal girl, and a night of no rape/kill, we are left with:
3 normal girls, 1 evil, one protector, one seer. Now assuming the seer didn't find the evil, one of those 3 normal girls is cleared, meaning we only have 2 uncleared normal girls and one evil to choose from, with three cleared girls.
Let's say we mislynch again, leaving us with 1 normal girl and 1 evil. Evil still can't kill the seer, because the rules say the only person a protector can't protect twice is herself, so lets say the demon kills the protector.
Seer will either find the demon or clear the last remaining good. Either way, we find and lynch the demon and good wins.
*******
tl;dr - Good wins 100% in both scenarios.
Let me address the two "flaws" that you found, DeMatt.
IF the demon declares herself special:
Then we have 4 cleared normal girls, and three suspects.
Next step is to say, "Okay, now good specials declare which special you ACTUALLY are." Seer says she's the seer. Protector says she's the protector. Evil now has to counter one and only one of those claims. Whichever person she doesn't counter is now clear as well giving us:
5 cleared vs two uncleared, one of which is evil. We lynch one of them, if game isn't over, we lynch the remaining one the next day and good is guaranteed victory.
************
Second scenario: Evil hits the protected seer, resulting in no death.
That means that after a day one lynch of a normal girl, and a night of no rape/kill, we are left with:
3 normal girls, 1 evil, one protector, one seer. Now assuming the seer didn't find the evil, one of those 3 normal girls is cleared, meaning we only have 2 uncleared normal girls and one evil to choose from, with three cleared girls.
Let's say we mislynch again, leaving us with 1 normal girl and 1 evil. Evil still can't kill the seer, because the rules say the only person a protector can't protect twice is herself, so lets say the demon kills the protector.
Seer will either find the demon or clear the last remaining good. Either way, we find and lynch the demon and good wins.
*******
tl;dr - Good wins 100% in both scenarios.